2025 Hugo Award Novel nominees: My thoughts!
The 2025 Hugo Awards for SFF works will be announced in August this year. I often like to have a stab at reading to the list for short stories, novels and novellas, and this time I had a big head start, having already read 4 of the 6 novels. Here are my thoughts on the novels! (Short version: I would give the award to either A Sorceress Comes to Call or Service Model, if I was making the decision :-) Best Novel Nominees 1. Alien Clay by Adrian Tchaikovsky: 7/10 This is good, if grim, dystopian writing. As always, Tchaikovsky nails the voice - Professor Arton Daghdev, the prisoner ecologist protagonist-narrator, is vividly real on the page, and the fact that not all the other characters are fully built is actually a consistent representation of the POV we are given (very few of the other prisoner-exile characters become all that real to the narrator either). The concept - thought enemies being exiled to a remote barely-habitable planet to end their lives in forced labour, in this c...